Philosophy Atlas

How Thinkers Disagree
Sign In
Text size
100%
Theme

Philosophy Atlas

Disputed Statements

Claims this atlas currently marks as unsettled or as tested and found false. A debated fact is one scholars hold competing positions on; a debunked one has been checked against the record and found not to hold. Both are kept in view rather than quietly smoothed over, with the reasoning that put each one where it stands.

180 statements.

Purva Mimamsa, Start Year-300

Purva Mimamsa, Schools of Philosophy

Standing

Concerns Start Year

Currently States -300

Jaimini's dates are not independently attested; the Mimamsa Sutra is generally placed between the fourth and second centuries BCE.

Source Mimamsa (Wikipedia)

Purva Mimamsa, Founded Date0650-01-01

Purva Mimamsa, Schools of Philosophy

Standing

Concerns Founded Date

Currently States 0650-01-01

The DATE column cannot hold the -300 BCE start-year already on record for Jaimini's Mimamsa Sutra. This instead dates Kumarila Bhatta's commentarial systematization, which Wikipedia calls the founding of the first sub-school of Mimamsa; 650 approximates '7th century CE'.

Source Mimamsa (Wikipedia)

Purva Mimamsa, End Year1200

Purva Mimamsa, Schools of Philosophy

Standing

Concerns End Year

Currently States 1200

1200 approximates the High Middle Ages decline Wikipedia describes; no precise closing date is given, and Purva Mimamsa's ritual concerns persist in diminished form within Hindu practice today, so this marks the end of the school's organized philosophical dominance, not a hard extinction date.

Source Mimamsa (Wikipedia)

Pyrrho of Elis, Birth Year-360

Pyrrho of Elis, Philosophers

Standing

Concerns Birth Year

Currently States -360

Ancient chronology for Pyrrho is approximate; c. 365 to c. 360 BCE are both cited in modern scholarship.

Source Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy

Pyrrho of Elis, Death Year-270

Pyrrho of Elis, Philosophers

Standing

Concerns Death Year

Currently States -270

c. 275 to c. 270 BCE are both cited.

Source Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy

Pyrrhonism, End Year210

Pyrrhonism, Schools of Philosophy

Standing

Concerns End Year

Currently States 210

Sextus Empiricus, writing in the late second or early third century CE, is the last major Pyrrhonist whose work survives, but later writers report individual Pyrrhonists as late as the sixth century CE, so there is no settled date for when the school itself ceased.

Source Pyrrhonism (Wikipedia)

Pythagoras, Death PlaceMetapontum, Magna Graecia (traditional account; some ancient sources instead say he was killed during the anti-Pythagorean persecution at Croton)

Pythagoras, Philosophers

Standing

Concerns Death Place

Currently States Metapontum, Magna Graecia (traditional account; some ancient sources instead say he was killed during the anti-Pythagorean persecution at Croton)

Ancient sources disagree on whether Pythagoras died in the persecution at Croton or escaped and died at Metapontum.

Source Pythagoras (Wikipedia)

Pythagoreanism, End Year-400

Pythagoreanism, Schools of Philosophy

Standing

Concerns End Year

Currently States -400

marks the decline of the original Pythagorean communities in southern Italy; the tradition was later revived in a philosophically distinct form as Neopythagoreanism.

Source Pythagoreanism (Wikipedia)

Qualia, Origin Year1929

Qualia, Concepts

Standing

Concerns Origin Year

Currently States 1929

The term traces to earlier twentieth century philosophical usage; its best known statement is the 1974 paper on bat experience referenced in the description.

Ramanuja, Birth Year1017

Ramanuja, Philosophers

Standing

Concerns Birth Year

Currently States 1017

Traditional dating gives 1017 to 1137 CE, an unusually long 120 year life; recent scholarship revises this to 1077 to 1157 CE, an 80 year life. 1017 is carried here as the traditional value.

Source Ramanuja (Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy)

Ramanuja, Death Year1137

Ramanuja, Philosophers

Standing

Concerns Death Year

Currently States 1137

Traditional dating; recent scholarship revises his death to 1157 CE. See the birth-year note.

Source Ramanuja (Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy)

Sage Philosophy, Start Year1978

Sage Philosophy, Schools of Philosophy

Standing

Concerns Start Year

Currently States 1978

Oruka's sage philosophy project developed through fieldwork conducted from the late 1970s into the 1980s; no single founding year is agreed on.

Source African Sage Philosophy (Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy)

Sage Philosophy, Founded Date1978-07-01

Sage Philosophy, Schools of Philosophy

Standing

Concerns Founded Date

Currently States 1978-07-01

Oruka announced his project in 1974 as Thoughts on Traditional Kenyan Sages, then first presented the term philosophic sagacity in July 1978; no single founding year is agreed on, matching this entity's own start-year note.

Source African Sage Philosophy (Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy)

Sage Philosophy, Start Year1974

Sage Philosophy, Schools of Philosophy

Standing

Concerns Start Year

Currently States 1974

The Internet Encyclopedia states Oruka first announced his project in 1974, four years before the 1978 value already on record for when he coined the term philosophic sagacity. Kept alongside rather than replacing the existing value.

Source African Sage Philosophy (Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy)

Sage Philosophy, Founded Date1974-01-01

Sage Philosophy, Schools of Philosophy

Standing

Concerns Founded Date

Currently States 1974-01-01

The Internet Encyclopedia states Oruka first announced his project in 1974, four years before the 1978-07-01 value already on record for when he coined the term philosophic sagacity. Kept alongside rather than replacing the existing value.

Source African Sage Philosophy (Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy)

School of Names, Start Year-400

School of Names, Schools of Philosophy

Standing

Concerns Start Year

Currently States -400

dated broadly to the era of Hui Shi and Gongsun Long in the fifth to third centuries BCE; individual dates for these figures are uncertain.

Source Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy

School of Names, End Year-221

School of Names, Schools of Philosophy

Standing

Concerns End Year

Currently States -221

the school did not survive as an organized tradition past the Qin unification, though its texts and puzzles continued to be discussed.

Source Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy

School of Names, Start Year-501

School of Names, Schools of Philosophy

Standing

Concerns Start Year

Currently States -501

Deng Xi is named by the Stanford Encyclopedia as the earliest figure associated with the School of Names, a century before the -400 value already on record for the Hui Shi and Gongsun Long era. All surviving information about him is second-hand, so this is a genuinely earlier but less certain estimate, kept alongside rather than replacing the existing value.

Source Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy

Seneca, Birth Year-4

Seneca, Philosophers

Standing

Concerns Birth Year

Currently States -4

The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy gives circa 1 BCE to CE 65; other reconstructions place his birth as early as 4 BCE. No exact birth year is independently attested.

Source Seneca (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy)

Shams al-Din al-Shahrazuri, Death Year1288

Shams al-Din al-Shahrazuri, Philosophers

Standing

Concerns Death Year

Currently States 1288

Alive in 1288, and also said to have died that year

Source Al-Shahrazuri, Wikipedia