Philosophy Atlas

How Thinkers Disagree
Sign In
Text size
100%
Theme
Schools of Philosophy

German Idealism

Metaphysics

A movement in German philosophy running from Kant's Critique of Pure Reason (1781) through Fichte and Schelling to its culmination in Hegel's system, unified by the claim that reality is not simply given to a passive mind but is structured, in some substantive sense, by mind or spirit itself. Kant's transcendental idealism, the argument that the mind actively structures experience through its own forms of intuition and categories of understanding rather than passively receiving a ready-made world, supplied the movement's founding insight; Fichte and Schelling each pushed the consequences of that insight further toward a fully idealist system, and Hegel completed the arc with a systematic account of Spirit (Geist) developing through history toward self-conscious freedom, set out across the Phenomenology of Spirit (1807), the Science of Logic (1812 to 1816) and the Elements of the Philosophy of Right (1820). German Idealism's influence reached well beyond academic philosophy, shaping Marx's dialectical materialism by inversion, Existentialism by reaction, and, through Coleridge and Carlyle's transmission of it into English letters, the American Transcendentalists.

Facts
Start Year
1781 2
The publication of Kant's Critique of Pure Reason, conventionally taken as the movement's founding text.
Founded Date
1781-01-01 2
Region
The German-speaking states of the Holy Roman Empire and, after 1806, the German Confederation, chiefly Prussia and Saxony 2
Disputed
End Year
1831 2
Hegel's death in 1831 is the conventional close of the movement's classical phase; some historians extend German Idealism's afterlife through Schopenhauer and into the 1840s before its eclipse by Marx's materialist reaction and by mid-century positivism.
Classification
Tradition
Continental 1
Learn More
The Mind That Builds Its Own World

This article records tradition as it has been passed down and reported. Its sources are not yet part of the atlas's verified catalogue.

Kant called it his own Copernican revolution, and the comparison is exact in a way that is easy to undersell. Copernicus did not discover a new fact about the heavens so much as move the observer: instead of asking why the sun and stars circle a stationary earth, ask what the observer's own motion would have to look like for the sky to appear the way it does, and the strange orbits resolve themselves. Kant did the same thing to the mind. Instead of asking how a passive mind manages to receive an accurate copy of a world already fully structured out there, independent of any observer, ask what the mind itself must be contributing for experience to have the shape it demonstrably has: objects in space, events in time, effects following causes in a lawlike order. His answer was that the mind is not a camera. It is closer to a mold. Space and time, on Kant's account, are not features of things as they are in themselves but forms the mind itself imposes on whatever it receives, the medium experience necessarily comes packaged in; and categories like causality are not read off the world by observation but supplied by the understanding as the very condition of anything counting as an experience of objects at all. The cost of this move is a permanent asterisk: we can know appearances, the world as it is structured by our own cognitive apparatus, but never things as they are in themselves, independent of any mind structuring them. Kant meant that asterisk to be a wall, a hard limit on speculative metaphysics. Fichte and Schelling, working in the decades right after him, read it instead as an invitation, and pushed on exactly the point Kant had tried to seal off: if the mind is already doing this much construction work, why assume there is an unknowable thing in itself sitting behind appearances at all, rather than mind, in some deeper and more active sense, going all the way down. Hegel took that invitation and built a whole system on it, arguing that reality just is Spirit, Geist, coming to know itself through a long historical unfolding, a process he traced from the barest immediate certainty of Phenomenology of Spirit's opening pages through art, religion and the state to what he called absolute knowing. It is tempting to read the arc from Kant's careful epistemological limits to Hegel's sweeping metaphysical system as a philosophy that simply lost its nerve, but it can be read the other way just as easily: as several thinkers in a row taking with full seriousness one insight Kant himself supplied, that the mind is not a passive mirror, and refusing to stop asking what else follows once you actually believe that.

Connections

Associated With

Source Friedrich Wilhelm Joseph von Schelling (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy)
Source Johann Gottlieb Fichte (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy)

Goethe's morphological and color-theoretical natural science was not itself German Idealist system-building, but it fed directly into the movement's philosophy of nature, most visibly in Hegel's own engagement with the Farbenlehre.

Source Johann Wolfgang von Goethe (Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy)

Founded By

Hegel is standardly named, alongside Fichte and Schelling, as one of the movement's founding and culminating figures, completing the post-Kantian idealist system.

Source German Idealism (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy)

Kant is standardly credited as the movement's originating figure through the Critique of Pure Reason's transcendental idealism, even though he is not himself always classified as a German Idealist in the narrower sense reserved for Fichte, Schelling and Hegel; this atlas already carries Kant's own tradition fact as German Idealism.

Source German Idealism (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy)

In Branch

Source Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy

Long-Form Articles

Sources
1. Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy
IEP, "German Idealism," opening paragraph
Quote, IEP, "German Idealism," opening paragraph
German idealism is the name of a movement in German philosophy that began in the 1780s and lasted until the 1840s.
View the Source
2. German Idealism (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy)
  • In Category: Schools of Philosophy
  • Founded By: Immanuel Kant, entry: German Idealism
  • Founded By: Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel, entry: German Idealism
Johann Wolfgang von Goethe (Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy)
Internet Encyclopedia of PhilosophyAssociated With: Johann Wolfgang von GoetheView the Source
Johann Gottlieb Fichte (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy)
Stanford Encyclopedia of PhilosophyAssociated With: Johann Gottlieb Fichte
Friedrich Wilhelm Joseph von Schelling (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy)
Stanford Encyclopedia of PhilosophyAssociated With: Friedrich Wilhelm Joseph Schelling
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Stanford University, Center for the Study of Language and InformationIn Branch: MetaphysicsView the Source
Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first to share a thought.
Reader Challenges (0)
No disputes yet. Spotted an error or a better source? Open the first one.