A foundational Legalist text traditionally attributed to Shang Yang, setting out the case for agriculture and warfare as the twin foundations of state strength, uniform law applied without exception, and the deliberate weakening of private virtue, learning, and commerce in favor of total loyalty to the ranking system of the state. Most scholars now regard it as a composite work, built up by later Legalist compilers around a core of ideas and possibly some material genuinely traceable to Shang Yang, rather than written by him alone.
Authorship is debated among sinologists; treated here as traditionally attributed rather than certainly authored.
Facts
Disputed
Publication YearScholars including Yuri Pines find the text was compiled over roughly a century, from material contemporary with or shortly after Shang Yang's own lifetime (390-338 BCE) to chapters dated as late as some eighty years after his death; -300 marks a representative point within the third century BCE window Wikipedia gives for the finished text, not a single attested compilation date. Classification
Genre / Form Original Language Connections
Authored By
Why this is disputed. Traditional attribution; modern scholarship treats the text as a later composite.
Source Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Belongs To Tradition
In Branch
Source Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Questions
Written In Form
Sources
1. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Stanford University, Center for the Study of Language and InformationStanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Legalism in Chinese Philosophy, section 3.2 Rewards: The Ranks of Merit
The system of 20 (initially fewer) ranks of merit introduced by Shang Yang was one of the most daring acts of social engineering in human history.
- Authored By: Shang Yang
- In Branch: Political Philosophy
View the Source 2. The Book of Lord Shang (Wikipedia)
WikipediaLead sectionQuote, Lead section
is an ancient Chinese text from the 3rd century BC, regarded as a foundational work of "Chinese Legalism"
Open Questions (1 open question)
Who Actually Wrote The Book of Lord Shang?
The text as it survives shows layered composition, differing terminology and doctrine across chapters, and references to events after the death of Shang Yang in 338 BCE, so it cannot be a single work set down by his own hand even if some chapters preserve genuine early material.
What would resolve this A securely dated early manuscript or a chapter-by-chapter philological study establishing which sections predate later Legalist compilers would let scholars separate any genuine Shang Yang material from later additions.
Classical Chinese philology and textual historyStanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Reader Challenges (0)
No disputes yet. Spotted an error or a better source? Open the first one.
Sign in to dispute this or suggest a correction.